Twitter Foils UK Celebrities’ Favorite Weapon: The Super-Injunction

Ryan Giggs. Photo: Allison Pasciuto

Ryan Giggs. Photo: Allison Pasciuto

The worst kept secret in Britain has been completely undermined by an onslaught of tweets. Chris Gayomali reviews the Ryan Giggs affair for TIME:

Earlier this month Ryan Giggs, a professional soccer player who plays for the U.K.’s Manchester United, obtained a court-ordered injunction to keep secret the details of an extra-marital affair with British television personality Imogen Thomas. The short story is that he didn’t want the U.K. press writing about his misconducts.

The move appeared to backfire, however, when news of the injunction spread like wildfire through over 70,000 Twitter accounts, causing Mr. Giggs to take up legal action against “persons unknown” as well as the social network itself.

Legal experts assumed that gag orders breached on Twitter were protected because the website is outside of the British legal system’s jurisdiction.

However, in a surprising move, a senior executive from Twitter admitted to the Telegraph that it would turn user information over to the authorities if it were “legally required” to.

British Attorney General Dominic Grieve had previously warned that people who broke injunctions online were in for a “”rude shock,” and the admission calls into question legal jurisdictions on the internet (which we’ve already discussed extensively). Depending on how this shakes out, the admission could also open the floodgates for similarly aggrieved celebrities to follow suit.

Yesterday, we wrote about how courts (albeit American ones) have previously ordered information accessible only through private Facebook accounts be made available in public litigation, which suggests a trend of willingness among the social networks to comply with the law. Of course, the implications could prove critical to a user’s right to free speech on the internet, but again, it raises a question we’ll continue to see: How far should these protections extend?

Users will always find ways to circumnavigate legalities and protect their online identities (fake email accounts, ISP-addresses, etc.), but the line become hazy when social networks are faced with the dilemma of protecting their users (usually in their best interest) while complying with the law…

[continues at TIME]

, , , ,

  • emperorreagan

    When will governments and the law understand that suppressing the flow of information is basically impossible?

    Governments can go to a lot of time and expense to attempt to stop the dissemination of information.  They can throw people into jail for spreading information and create an atmosphere of fear.  Neither thing, though, will stop the flow of information.

    Also, governments shouldn’t be in the business of protecting asshole footballers from embarrassment when they can’t keep their dicks in their pants.   

  • emperorreagan

    When will governments and the law understand that suppressing the flow of information is basically impossible?

    Governments can go to a lot of time and expense to attempt to stop the dissemination of information.  They can throw people into jail for spreading information and create an atmosphere of fear.  Neither thing, though, will stop the flow of information.

    Also, governments shouldn’t be in the business of protecting asshole footballers from embarrassment when they can’t keep their dicks in their pants.   

  • Hamsanath437

    It’s kind of appalling that the british government might be taking legal action against twitter in order to protect a soccer player’s right to have an affair and cover it up. 

  • Hamsanath437

    It’s kind of appalling that the british government might be taking legal action against twitter in order to protect a soccer player’s right to have an affair and cover it up. 

  • Darthtim23

    “Ryan Giggs, Ryan Giggs
    Cherished by the scum
    Ryan Giggs, Ryan Giggs
    Ferguson is his mum
    Sponsored by Reebok
    Looks like Doctor Spock
    Ryan Giggs, Ryan Giggs….”

    (sorry, I couldn’t resist bursting into song :D)

  • Darthtim23

    “Ryan Giggs, Ryan Giggs
    Cherished by the scum
    Ryan Giggs, Ryan Giggs
    Ferguson is his mum
    Sponsored by Reebok
    Looks like Doctor Spock
    Ryan Giggs, Ryan Giggs….”

    (sorry, I couldn’t resist bursting into song :D)

21