How The U.S. Media Squashes Dissent

activistFrom oft-acclaimed and criticized political cartoonist Ted Rall, writing for Al Jazeera:

The American media deploys a deep and varied arsenal of rhetorical devices in order to marginalise opinions, people and organisations as “outside the mainstream” and therefore not worth listening to. For the most part the people and groups being declaimed belong to the political Left. To take one example, the Green Party – well-organised in all 50 states – is never quoted in newspapers or invited to send a representative to television programmes that purport to present “both sides” of a political issue. (In the United States, “both sides” means the back-and-forth between centre-right Democrats and rightist Republicans.)

Marginalisation is the intentional decision to exclude a voice in order to prevent a “dangerous” opinion from gaining currency, to block a politician or movement from becoming more powerful, or both. In 2000, the media-backed consortium that sponsored the presidential debate between Vice President Al Gore and Texas Governor George W. Bush banned Green Party candidate Ralph Nader from participating. Security goons even threatened to arrest him when he showed up with a ticket and asked to be seated in the audience.

In 2000, debate bosses excluded Nader using the excuse that his support (as measured by public opinion polls) was too insignificant to impact the election.That assessment was dubious at best. Most analysts believe that Nader drew enough liberal votes away from Al Gore to cost him the state of Florida, which handed the election to Bush (This is not my assessment. The 2000 race was stolen by corrupt Florida election officials and a judicial coup d’etat carried out by the US Supreme Court). The point remains: Nader was denied access to the debates, and to coverage by the TV networks, because he wasn’t an “important” candidate. Yet those same networks argue that he changed the course of the election.

“Over the past few weeks, Washington has seemed dysfunctional,” conservative columnist David Brooks opined recently in The New York Times. “Public disgust [about the debt ceiling crisis] has risen to epic levels. Yet through all this, serious people – Barack Obama, John Boehner, the members of the Gang of Six – have soldiered on.”

Here’s some of what Peter Coy of Business Week magazine had to say about the same issue: “There is a comforting story about the debt ceiling that goes like this: Back in the 1990s, the US was shrinking its national debt at a rapid pace. Serious people actually worried about dislocations from having too little government debt …”

Fox News, the Murdoch-owned house organ of America’s official right-wing, asserted: “No one seriously thinks that the US will not honour its obligations, whatever happens with the current impasse on President Obama’s requested increase to the government’s $14.3tn borrowing limit.”

Big US media uses the “serious people”/”nobody seriously thinks” marginalisation meme on numerous subjects, but none so often as on war. You guessed it: “Serious people” think wars are necessary and must continue indefinitely. “No one seriously thinks” that the American military can “just” stop fighting a war without suffering all sorts of terrible consequences: “Instability”. Becoming viewed by allies as “unreliable”. Creating a “power vacuum”. Allowing an already difficult situation to deteriorate “even further”. Sure, people are suffering and dying now. But if the US leaves, many more people will die. In order to avert a theoretical bloodbath of the future, the United States is obligated to continue its present, sustainable rate of killing and maiming.

In this wacky topsy-turvy world, where the people who are usually wrong get to lord it over those who usually get it right, abject failures like Obama and Boehner – who make logical assertions that are nothing but, and who have presided over fiscal collapse while not making the slightest effort to stimulate the economy with public works and other classic Keynesian responses to the global depression – are lauded as Serious People.

Throughout the last few years, especially since Obama took office in January 2009 and after the death of Osama bin Laden earlier this year, calls to withdraw from one or both of America’s major quagmires have been met with media claims by Very Serious People along the lines that “no one seriously thinks we can just withdraw”.

According to a June 21, 2011 Pew Research poll, 56 per cent of Americans favour immediate withdrawal of US occupation troops from Afghanistan. Many of these antiwar voters know that there could be negative ramifications; the same percentage believes that the Karzai regime will collapse without a US military presence. So it is not not true that “no one” thinks we can withdraw. In fact, most people think we should withdraw. And many of them are willing to countenance the possibility that the Taliban would win an ensuing civil war.

For “their” newspapers, radio and television journalists, however, these people – over half the population – don’t count. They are “no one”. They are certainly not “serious people” who have done the hard thinking. They are not, in other favourite meme, “realistic” or “pragmatic”.

“We can’t leave Afghanistan at this juncture,” former US National Security Council member Rick Nelson told ABC News after US commandos assassinated Osama bin Laden. “There is still a significant terrorist threat emanating from western Pakistan.” The US must “commit the resources, personnel, and money against this threat until we are certain that it is completely dismantled”, said Nelson, talking as though to a small, slightly dim, child. To which such a child might reasonably respond: How would one know that such a threat had completely vanished? Fortunately for Nelson, ABC’s excuse for a journalist didn’t follow up.

“So why not just get out?” asked Newsweek’s John Barry in 2009. “As always, it’s not so simple.”

Sure it is.

To paraphrase my fellow political cartoonist Matt Bors, US soldiers could go to the airport. They could board planes. They could go home.

Back to the debt ceiling crisis.

For many Americans the gravity and absurdity of the current economy was crystallised by news accounts that Apple Computer had more ready cash on hand than the US Treasury ($76bn versus $74bn).

Apple isn’t alone. “Corporations collectively are hoarding more cash than ever before, posting glowing balance sheets,” reports International Business Times. “At the end of 2010, companies held an estimated $1.9tn of excess cash, and so far in 2011 most have not let go.” US banks, says The Washington Post, have more than $2tn available to lend.

If you’ve read Karl Marx you can probably imagine a solution to the US debt ceiling crisis. The government is poor but giant corporations are rich. Why doesn’t the Obama Administration appropriate the necessary sums from private companies and wealthy individuals via taxes or nationalisation? The Post answers: “But while the country is flush with assets, it doesn’t mean the government can seize them to pay for public debt.”

Why not? The article doesn’t say. Nor does it use the dreaded phrase “no one seriously thinks that …” But it’s there all the same. Because the US doesn’t officially countenance socialist economic solutions, advocates of European-style socialised medicine were dismissed by President Obama as naïve (and not Serious). Even when the federal government transferred hundreds of billions of dollars to banks and insurance companies during the 2008-09 meltdown, calls for accountability were dismissed as unrealistic. Not pragmatic. Nationalisation? Definitely not serious. Clownlike, really.

As Daniel Larison says, the track record of the Serious Ones is atrocious. And yet, on one story after another, even relatively minor ones, the US media continues to turn yesterday’s “no one thinks” into today’s “everyone knows”.

, , , ,

  • Anarchy Pony

    As George Carlin said, “It’s all bullshit folks, it’s all bullshit and it’s bad for ya.”

  • Wanooski

    As George Carlin said, “It’s all bullshit folks, it’s all bullshit and it’s bad for ya.”

  • Wanooski

    As George Carlin said, “It’s all bullshit folks, it’s all bullshit and it’s bad for ya.”

  • Elmyr23

    Nice write up. On the point of fox news and running the american right. One thing i don’t think most people think of is that murdok is not american. He was not raised to believe in american values or to believe in americans. He is not a patriot by anymeans. Yet some how he runs Fox news the “most american/patriotic” news making t.v. programming. 

    • http://www.youtube.com/user/ZYCERIN Zycerin

      What’s is even more interesting is the family history behind R.Murdoch and it’s political ties. It’s enough to make the normal righty cringe!!

      Of course it just strengthens my personal argument that he is simply a brilliant businessman that most of our Americans are too damn naive to recognize.

      • Anarchy Pony

        Brilliant businessman is practically synonymous with super villain.

        • http://www.youtube.com/user/ZYCERIN Zycerin

          Exactly! ;)

    • http://www.facebook.com/redsoxphil8 Philip Durnin

      Its a TV show. They are appealing to a base that has not been represented properly in the Mainstream News industry. Its all business.

  • Elmyr23

    Nice write up. On the point of fox news and running the american right. One thing i don’t think most people think of is that murdok is not american. He was not raised to believe in american values or to believe in americans. He is not a patriot by anymeans. Yet some how he runs Fox news the “most american/patriotic” news making t.v. programming. 

  • DeepCough

    Freedom of speech is definitely the most maligned civil right in the United States.

  • DeepCough

    Freedom of speech is definitely the most maligned civil right in the United States.

  • http://twitter.com/CoffinRide M.C. CoffinRide

     ”Nationalisation? Definitely not serious. Clownlike, really.”

    Tea Party by definition.

  • http://twitter.com/CoffinRide M.C. CoffinRide

     ”Nationalisation? Definitely not serious. Clownlike, really.”

    Tea Party by definition.

    • ICE

      nationalism just shows which government you bend over backwards for.

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/ZYCERIN Zycerin

    What’s is even more interesting is the family history behind R.Murdoch and it’s political ties. It’s enough to make the normal righty cringe!!

    Of course it just strengthens my personal argument that he is simply a brilliant businessman that most of our Americans are too damn naive to recognize.

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/ZYCERIN Zycerin

    Oh, Nader….he will always have my political support. Even if it will always remain in my lil’ black heart and will probably never serve him personally any use. You sir are a true patriot.

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/ZYCERIN Zycerin

    Oh, Nader….he will always have my political support. Even if it will always remain in my lil’ black heart and will probably never serve him personally any use. You sir are a true patriot.

  • Wanooski

    Brilliant businessman is practically synonymous with super villain.

  • http://www.youtube.com/user/ZYCERIN Zycerin

    Exactly! ;)

  • Quint X

    Yes, lets nationalize the richies! Because the state and our benevolent overlords are so competent and capable. Everything the state does always turns to roses and gold! Great idea! Let’s just steal what we need! No moral hazard there at all!

  • Quint X

    Yes, lets nationalize the richies! Because the state and our benevolent overlords are so competent and capable. Everything the state does always turns to roses and gold! Great idea! Let’s just steal what we need! No moral hazard there at all!

    • Anarchy Pony

      Go suck some right libertarian koch.

      • The Grey Area

        Well, I think the point both of you may in fact agree on is that the State is currently under “private ownership,” and this plan might not be as effective as we would want…

        • razzlebathbone

          Unfortunately, it looks like the government will have to be overthrown. Even more unfortunately, the new government that arises in its place will have to declare war on the corporations, seize their assets and execute their boards of directors.

          • do not disturb

            and enforce mandatory casual fridays for funsies  

        • Anarchy Pony

          Well that’s what always fucking happens in representative democracy. One of the most corruptable forms of governance.

    • Tuna Ghost

      Basically?  Yeah.  I have no moral objections whatsoever to stealing from Apple or Phillip Morris or any other corporation that posts record-breaking profits while wages have remained the same or dropped in the last ten years, while cutting jobs, while cutting benefits.  The only thing I don’t like about that scenario is that I can’t steal enough.  I only have two hands, after all.

  • http://carlclarkcomedy.blogspot.com/ CarlClarkComedy

    We are the Media. Wave your flag. Comment Post videos.  Join the Revolution already gosh

  • http://carlclarkcomedy.blogspot.com/ CarlClarkComedy

    We are the Media. Wave your flag. Comment Post videos.  Join the Revolution already gosh

  • http://carlclarkcomedy.blogspot.com/ CarlClarkComedy

    We are the Media. Wave your flag. Comment Post videos.  Join the Revolution already gosh

  • http://buzzcoastin.posterous.com BuzzCoastin

    Corporations own the Homeland government and the Homeland’s “free press” is supported by corporate advertising. Nothing makes it into the mainstream media that is not first CIA/NSA approved.

    Just try and find anything in mainstream media about the Bush/Obama CIA connection or anything other than the box-cutter bullshit about 9/11.

  • BuzzCoastin

    Corporations own the Homeland government and the Homeland’s “free press” is supported by corporate advertising. Nothing makes it into the mainstream media that is not first CIA/NSA approved.

    Just try and find anything in mainstream media about the Bush/Obama CIA connection or anything other than the box-cutter bullshit about 9/11.

  • Wanooski

    Go suck some right libertarian koch.

  • Wanooski

    Go suck some right libertarian koch.

  • The Grey Area

    Well, I think the point both of you may in fact agree on is that the State is currently under “private ownership,” and this plan might not be as effective as we would want…

  • Anonymous

    Unfortunately, it looks like the government will have to be overthrown. Even more unfortunately, the new government that arises in its place will have to declare war on the corporations, seize their assets and execute their boards of directors.

  • ICE

    nationalism just shows which government you bend over backwards for.

  • do not disturb

    and enforce mandatory casual fridays for funsies  

  • do not disturb

    and enforce mandatory casual fridays for funsies  

  • Wanooski

    Well that’s what always fucking happens in representative democracy. One of the most corruptable forms of governance.

  • Dueyv9

    *****CENSORED BY FOX NEWS*******

  • Dueyv9

    *****CENSORED BY FOX NEWS*******

  • Dueyv9

    *****CENSORED BY FOX NEWS*******

  • http://www.facebook.com/redsoxphil8 Philip Durnin

    Its a TV show. They are appealing to a base that has not been represented properly in the Mainstream News industry. Its all business.

  • Okarin

    one small step for man, one giant step ontop of mankind

  • Okarin

    one small step for man, one giant step ontop of mankind

    • Anarchy Pony

      A jack boot stamping down on a human face forever.

  • http://voxmagi-necessarywords.blogspot.com/ VoxMagi

    Bright side: I love those gorgeous moments when someone on TV manages to say something out loud that causes a moment of horror and sudden silence while the well practiced stooges scramble to find a way to segue as fast as they can without looking like desperate hacks. :-) Their suffering is my joy.

  • http://voxmagi-necessarywords.blogspot.com/ VoxMagi

    Bright side: I love those gorgeous moments when someone on TV manages to say something out loud that causes a moment of horror and sudden silence while the well practiced stooges scramble to find a way to segue as fast as they can without looking like desperate hacks. :-) Their suffering is my joy.

  • Wanooski

    A jack boot stamping down on a human face forever.

  • Tuna Ghost

    Basically?  Yeah.  I have no moral objections whatsoever to stealing from Apple or Phillip Morris or any other corporation that posts record-breaking profits while wages have remained the same or dropped in the last ten years, while cutting jobs, while cutting benefits.  The only thing I don’t like about that scenario is that I can’t steal enough.  I only have two hands, after all.