South Africa’s Political Wars Begin To Resemble Our Own

Cape Town, South Africa: When I came to South Africa, I thought I was escaping the way our news programs are totally dominated by political coverage even though the election is months away and everyone knows none of this polling and hyped-up speculation matters until October.

The fight between the Democrats and Republicans is an obscenely costly affair which none of our political pundits care to investigate in terms of why so much is being invested and what the likely payoffs will be, and to whom.

Business Day, the Wall Street Journal of South Africa, featured an essay recently with a headline that offers insight into the motivation of politicians in both countries: “PUBLIC OFFICE JUST A WAY TO PILLAGE THE STATE.”

In the US, of course, we have two principal parties, almost like two wings on a plane. The Republicans, now the captive of the hard right and the Democrats, firmly ensconced in the center, partial to corporations but with some issues and positions that appeal to liberals and even, parts of the left.

Obama is posturing at being a progressive on domestic social issues while refusing to crack down on Wall Street fraud, and promoting Bush-style war on terror military interventions. Romney is running on a one point program: blame Obama for everything wrong in the world.

Both parties are beholden to money and the people who supply it. We are talking billions! Of course, this immense money power corrupts the whole system. The Supreme Court has just ratified the decision that allows it.

In South Africa, corruption doesn’t grow out of the competition between two parties with more in common that you’d think. Here, there’s only one party that really matters–The African National Congress (ANC) that is riven by factions, ambitious politicians and an environment of jostling for power and position. Corruption is embarrassingly all too blatant while basic needs go unmet.

No one quite expected this when the world cheered as Nelson Mandela was swept into office in 1994. He had an ambitious program for ending poverty and transforming the country. People spoke of the changes in South Africa as a “miracle,” branding the country a “rainbow nation.”

Reality quickly set it. Racial division was only one of many economic and social problems all impervious to quick fixes. The government soon found that it had to overcome many forms of resistance to change including the vested interests of the business sector, the status quo orientation of international agencies like the IMF and World Bank as well as the go-slow counsel of Britain and the US.

A long suppressed black middle class wanted what it thought was its due and wanted it now! Inexperienced politicians luxuriated with new perks and fancy cars quickly putting its needs as an elite ahead of demands from its constituencies. Corruption soon surfaced and was largely ignored. The unity of the liberation struggle gave way to power games of every kind.

The Mail &Guardian has political scientist Achille Mbembe saying in a debate in Johannesburg, “after 18 years of relative complacency and self-congratulatory gestures” the ANC was realizing South Africa was an ordinary country and not a miracle.

South Africa’s miracle of the ’90s “can now be better categorized as a stalemate,” he said. “ One of the main tensions in South African politics is that its constitutional democracy did not erase the apartheid landscape.”

But, then, AIDS emerged as a fatal health problem catching the country off guard. Its health infrastructure had been crippled by years of apartheid underfunding. Early projections suggested that virtually the entire State treasury would have to be diverted to stop millions from dying. There was denial and stigma.

That was one of the realities confronting Mandela’s deputy and successor, Thabo Mbeki. That may help explain his attempts to downplay the AIDS threat and find others to blame for it. Mbeki had ambitions notions of an “African renaissance,” and turned South Africa into a force on the Continent while also alienating members of the ANC at home who resented what they saw as arrogance and elitism.

Although re-elected, he became a divisive force in the Party and was toppled before he could finish his second term. This was all evidence of democracy within the ANC, but also the emergence of other splits and splinters, as well as chaotic factions with the ANC’s own youth League demanding nationalization of the mines. (This demand was treated as an example of “radical populism” by some, and as a tactic to shake down industrialists for bribes by others even thought it did point to a certain laxness in the government’s unwillingness to crack down on business. Sound familiar?)

Former ANC exile and military chief Jacob Zuma toppled Mbeki with populist rhetoric—he sang a Zulu song, “Bring Me My Machine Gun” during his camapaign even though he was caught up in a personal corruption scandal that he narrowly slithered out of.

Now, some of the same pressures facing Mbeki are facing him, as supporters rally to his Deputy President Kglalema Mothlane or Zuma’s Minister of Settlements, the charismatic former guerilla turned billionaire, Tokyo Sexwale. Both seem poised to want to replace him

Meanwhile, the ANC is running a key policy conference to debate a document calling for a “Second Transition.” Mothlane recently sneered at the idea in a speech saying, “Second Transition! Second Transition! From where to where? What constituted the first transition?”

In response, President Zuma, has, according to the Mail & Guardian, “launched a veiled attack” on Kgalema for questioning the “Second Transition.” The crusading newspaper also reports:

“Supporters of ANC president Jacob Zuma will stop any attempts to discuss leadership issues at the ruling party’s policy conference this week.

This is the unyielding view of sources within the ruling party, who told the Mail & Guardian they will “suppress” any attempts to discuss succession within the ruling party.”

So much for the state of internal debate, yet clearly Zuma knows he’s a facing a serious internal fight.

Even as the politicians scramble for positions, criticism mounts of how South Africa is being governed. Law Professor Koos Malan, challenges the way public office here is misused, writing, “public office somehow entitles public office-bearers to exploit the power and authority of public office to achieve maximum private gain…and to receive public accolades for these successes.”

As the country prepares to mark Nelson Mandela’s 94th birthday in July, South Africa is also facing a dangerous downtown in its economy thanks to the world financial crisis, and soaring crime and unemployment.

The spirit of many here remains infectious but there’s trouble on the horizon.

News Dissector Danny Schechter blogs at newsdissector.net. He is the director of the film Plunder: The Crime of our Time. His two latest books are Blogothon and Occupy: Dissecting Occupy Wall Street. He also hosts a program on Progressive Radio Network.com. This article first appeared on Press TV in Iran. I wonder how they will respond. Comments to dissector@mediachanel.org

, , ,

2 Responses to South Africa’s Political Wars Begin To Resemble Our Own

  1. Zenc June 26, 2012 at 1:41 am #

    Unlike the politicians in the United States, the politicians there at least have a good excuse for finding themselves in the mess they’re in.

    International financial institutions took advantage of their naivete and put a world class screwing on the post-apartheid South African government which essentially doomed it to failure before it even got started.

    The politicians in the U.S. can only claim willful ignorance or intentional stupidity in the face of the burgeoning financial crisis which is of their own making.

  2. Mark Collins June 27, 2012 at 3:21 pm #

    South African Disinfo reader here,

    I have no idea what Zenc is talking about below, South Africa has a very strong financial sector and we have credit regulators that protected us from the shockwave caused by the credit crunch and ensuing recession.

    The most worrying thing in South Africa is the hatred toward white people, politicians often advocate violence toward White people as a general whole in public with no fear. Rights groups always lay charges but our legal system, constitution and judicial system have been under constant attack from the ANC to the point where it has become crippled financially as well as politically. Just recently the Chief Justice of our Constitutional court was appointed with relatively no experience and with many controversial judgments including marital rape. In spite of the many other candidates who had heaps more experience and merit. 

    Most of the failures made by governments are instantly blamed on apartheid or the white population in general, to the point where they have become virtually unaccountable to the masses. White people are hated and murders happen every few days. For more information research the Boer genocide that has been happening over the past few years

    It really is a sad state of affairs. The generation looking for jobs today were born out of apartheid and yet there is reverse apartheid legislation in place that legally forces companies and educational institutions to place favor to black individuals, to the point that it is discriminatory. Just recently there was a massive scandal with white students being unable to study veterinary science with 7+ distinctions because black students were getting all the placements with requirements that were C and D averages for their high school diplomas.

    Another scandal was the recent failure of government to deliver textbooks to schools within one of our northern states, to the point where a high court had to force them to deliver textbooks as they were contravening our constitution by not doing so. Of course they still defied the court order deadline a month+ later and did nor or could not deliver textbooks.

Leave a Reply