A Shutdown or A Coup? How It Was Engineered

What is the Tea Party and where did it come from? Was it a grass roots movement nurtured in the bowels of deep dissatisfaction in the American electorate with “big government” and its inexorable turn towards Socialism?

Hate to disappoint folks who buy the populist revolt theory. Anyone remember the mad rant of Rick Santelli in 2009? He’s a fixture on the pro-business channel CNBC who actually was first to call for a Tea Party by millionaires in Chicago to protest against any relief for homeowners who were on the verge of being foreclosed upon.

It was this loudmouth who used his bully pulpit on the floor of the Chicago Board of Trade to make the original call.

The idea resonated with the armies of the resentful who always feel l that the government should not help those in need—characterizing them as people living in bigger houses than they can afford and unfairly demanding a bailout from tax payers.

Rick and the traders cheering for him apparently never heard about or cared about predatory lending and bank practices that have since led to massive fines and paybacks for years of mortgage scams.

No, to righteous “rebels” like Rick and Co, it was the people who were to blame and who deserve the tongue-lashing and class hatred that flowed out of his mouth against “the losers” backed by the media mouths of his minions.

They call themselves traders, but traitors might be used as well.

When Santelli got some attention from his fellow ideologues, the Republican right seized the idea.

Suddenly this bottom-up people’s movement was repackaged as a  top-down political army by bringing together the Christian Right, professional pols, and Right—wing political consultants who followed a strategy of intimidation and demagoguery,  aided and abetted by media outlets like Fox and their fellow travelers of the Beck and Limbaugh variety.

They sought out a unifying issues based on systematic distortions of the facts while appeal to the fears they had themselves reinforced. The fact that the President is black added fuel to their bombast even if they realized early on, they had to conceal their racial hostility and tone down their Hatred.

Opposing what they labeled Obamacare became their organizing principle larding on to it, fear of “death panels,” and an assault on basic freedom. Never mind the millions without health care. Who cares about them?

The Democrats were bullied early on to reject using the successful Social Security-like workable Medicare model or single payer system and adopt instead a corporate based approach that would further enrich the insurance companies and is, in fact, riddled with contradictions.

What the Republicans hid was that it was based on Republican ideas, as Mark Karlin at Buzzflash/Truthout explains:

“As hard as it is to believe given the psychotic babble coming out of the mouths of House Republicans, the Affordable Care Act was the creation of a think tank revered by conservatives, the Heritage Institute, and promoted by Republicans in the early ’90s as an alternative to “Hillarycare.”

“Of course, none other than Mitt Romney made it his main legacy as governor of Massachusetts; i.e., that is to say before he retroactively denounced it to jump on the anti-Obamacare juggernaut in the GOP primaries.”

Their single-minded campaign distorting health care as Obama Care, a phrase that Obama later warmed to has now led to the takeover of the House of Representatives and the shutdown of the government.

A well-funded campaign to knock off moderate Republicans and replace them with this simplistic Angry Brigade created a think- alive force that soon learned the tricks of Congressional longevity like gerrymandering districts to make them unchallengeable and voter suppression tactics to keep the minority vote down.

All of this was orchestrated in the shadows by operatives and funded by right-leaning billionaires thanks to the Supreme Court’s Citizen United decision.

Unfortunately, the left is given more to protesting than politics and did not compete, in part, because of its own disgust with all the money and immorality in politics.

Disillusioned by a President who wanted nothing to do with their values, they mostly withdrew from conventional politics into movements like Occupy Wall Street and issue-oriented campaigning. The labor unions, long the mainstay of Democratic Party politics, started shriveling in influence and turned into fundraisers, not marching feet.

The Right almost had the field to themselves even though Democratic Battle axes like Harry Reid who kept the Senate in line, delaying and frustrating the coup that is still underway.

Writing on the site Truth Dig, Bill Boyarsky, warned:

“Don’t write the Republicans off as totally crazy. They know that if Obamacare works, it will wreck chances for attaining their real goal—lowering taxes on the rich, wiping out regulations and widening even more the gap between the very rich and everyone else.

That is why they and their business allies are fighting so hard against the Affordable Care Act and seeking to bring the federal government to a halt. If the Republicans lose on Obamacare, it will be nearly impossible for them to shrink government the way they’ve been dreaming.”

Reverend Jesse Jackson puts the current crisis in a historical context that I have yet to see in the media:

“We’re not talking the Boston Tea Party here. We’re talking the Fort Sumter Tea Party. We’re talking about a modern, right-wing movement built on a new Republican South in reaction to the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Voting Rights Act of 1965. A “Southern Strategy” led by Strom Thurmond and Jesse Helms led directly to the elections of Richard Nixon and Ronald Reagan and eventually to Speaker Newt Gingrich and President George W. Bush.

The Fort Sumter Tea Party has never accepted the legitimacy of Barack Obama’s presidency. A huge chunk of the right wing has subjected the first African-American president to massive abuse, name-calling, and vicious threats.

Unfortunately, due to John Boehner’s lack of leadership in the House, the tea party minority faction now dictates policy and rhetoric to the entire GOP.
This means that the GOP continues to try to delegitimize, defund and delay Obamacare. They have spent the last 5 years trying to keep poor and working Americans from getting health care. This is wrong, it’s immoral, and it’s very undemocratic, since Barack Obama was re-elected by a large margin.”

This shut-down of the government is not about too much federal spending or how to make health care really affordable. It’s not even about Obama or the Democrats. It’s about realigning politics, and putting an extreme minority political movement in permanent power. As both sides blame each other, few solutions are in sight.

Can it be stopped? Will it be?

This crisis exposes the structural problems in our politics and calls attention the contempt a majority of Americans have for both the Congress and this movement of nullification.  Obama seems to lack the fortitude to really stand up to the hostage takers. He has not given in but he hasn’t prevailed.

Where are the leaders and the movements who can turn this disgraceful low moment in our political life around?


News Dissector Danny Schechter blogs at NewsDissector.net and edits Mediachannel.org. Comments to dissector@mediachannel.org.

13 Comments on "A Shutdown or A Coup? How It Was Engineered"

  1. Charlie Primero | Oct 2, 2013 at 9:12 am |

    Is Disinfo really sinking to this level of low-brow political shlock?

    I mean, does Disinfo really want to attact the type of person who gets excited by stuff like this? Traffic is one thing, quality traffic is quite another.

    • God forbid we spare a few inches on the front page for real world events in between climate change denial and bigfoot hunter articles.

  2. Liam_McGonagle | Oct 2, 2013 at 9:37 am |

    Historical movements are rarely uni-valent. There must be some type of ostensible quid-pro-quo understanding for anything to happen.

    Which is not to say that the understanding is correct, or fully shared by all parties. In fact, I would say it’s usually the case that at least one party to any given transaction has a serious misundertanding of his/her counterpary’s true intent.

    Yes, of course Tea Baggers are ridiculous buffoons. But I’d wager only an incredibly small (yet influential) handful of them are the carefully considered sociopaths the public believes them to be.

    The vast majority are merely ignorant. No shortage of ignorant.

  3. JAlfredPrufrock | Oct 2, 2013 at 9:54 am |

    I try to avoid reading about the Tea Party as i know its only going to irritate me. I thought today I would give it a go, just to see – sure enough its pissed me right off!

    Sometimes ignorance truly is bliss.

  4. emperorreagan | Oct 2, 2013 at 10:19 am |

    I read an article here or someplace else that basically stated that the republicans were so successful in their gerrymandering efforts in the past couple of decades that they’ve destabilized their own party – instead of trying to fend off challenges from the center/left democrats, they now are fighting off internal challenges from the extreme right. I think that’s pretty spot on.

    And the right wing has been engaged in particularly ugly activity for decades, like the southern strategy mentioned in the article. There’s a decades long effort of race baiting and disinformation to get people to vote against their own interests – like the successful effort to seed the image of a black woman with children by multiple men gaming the social welfare system as the face of social services into the public consciousness.

  5. doodahman | Oct 2, 2013 at 11:59 am |

    heh. Quoting Jesse Jackson. Nice way to blow your credibility. I thought this was a website about the arcane and the occult–not shilling screeds for the Democrats. Why not take your centrist claptrap over to HuffinStuff Post where they can feed it to their nincompoops?

  6. I’m not sure you can stop corporate feudalists with words.

  7. i am not a democrat. i am not a republican. obama sucks on so many levels, the guy is a war criminal and an incredibly loyal acolyte of american imperialism and neolberialism– but goddamn if you are a right-winger you are fucking either just rich and evil or weak-minded and ignorant. personally i am glad to see disinfo posting some political commentary, despite a quote from jesse jackson haha. extreme corruption exists in our broken democracy, but the right is historically more to blame for how fucked everything is. read books, some of them are informative. there’s more than 2 sides to every issue, even in a “polarized” 2-party system.

  8. The author wants us to believe that the Affordable Care Act (ObamneyCare) is a real boon to those without healthcare. Not only am I losing coverage via my spouses coverage via her employer, we won’t be able to afford for me to have health care via the ACA.

    So these jack*sses on the Left who think this ACA is a dream realized are pulling the wool over their own eyes.

    And the author quotes Jesse Jackson? Mr Hymietown himself?

    This article was a waste of pixels.

  9. Lookinfor Buford | Oct 2, 2013 at 1:58 pm |

    “Obama seems to lack the fortitude to really stand up to the hostage takers. He has not given in but he hasn’t prevailed.”
    I suppose the author believes Obama should just rule by Edict on this one.
    Cuz that would be a step in the right direction, huh?
    The argument today is the same one we’ve been having since before the Revolutionary war.
    Do the people need to be controlled and managed by the Government?
    Or is it the Government that needs to be controlled and managed by the people?

  10. It’s an Old Right Revival!

    American Liberty League

    Sounds familiar, doesn’t it? Let’s hope they’re around just as long.

  11. alizardx | Oct 4, 2013 at 1:17 am |

    Author more or less right on Tea Party origin and astroturf-style organizational techniques, though non-news to anyone paying attention at the time.

    Did anyone here NOT know the wife of the Tea Party shutdown leader, Ted Cruz works for Goldman Sachs? For more info on Tea Party funding, use:
    “Dick Armey” “Tea Party” funding
    as search terms. You’ll find Wall Street largely behind this. Though historically, right-wing “populism” almost exclusively funded by the wealthy. It’s a tradition.

    As for the “vampire squid”, Obama ties to Goldman Sachs are pretty well known. (Remember Larry Summers?)

    However, with respect to Obamacare (aka Romneycare/Hillarycare) single payer national health plan was never seriously considered. What we got was a taxpayer pipeline into Big Insurance bank accounts and enshrinement of Big Health/Big Pharma profit status quo essentially mandated by law. In exchange for chump change in the form of end-user subsidies (passthrough to insurance) and Community Health Centers.

    BTW, Big Health / Pharma / Insurance largely synonymous with Wall Street; they see this as a big profit growth area for some reason. Assume one thing. Whatever it is that they’re planning, it’s not an attack on their own Obamacare-fed bank accounts.

    What do the money interests behind both Democrats and GOP really want from the shutdown? Watch the “Great Compromise” that will end it. See what Democratic constituency gets thrown under the bus, and who will profit from this. Remember the “Catfood Commission”?

    If you’re thinking that I’m suggesting that the shutdown is Tea Party Congresscritters providing Obama with political cover to do what he really wants to do without their knowing it, you’re right.

Comments are closed.