How the Houston Cop Who Killed an Unarmed, Disabled Man Was Found Innocent

Apparently Houston cops can kill and get away with it. This time it was a mentally ill double amputee with a pen.

via Texas Observer

Police misconduct in shootings is “very very difficult” to prove, FBI agent says.

On October 24, the Houston Police Department announced the results of its yearlong investigation into the shooting death of Brian Claunch, a mentally ill double amputee killed by an officer last September after refusing to drop a pen. HPD cleared the officer, Matthew Marin, of any wrongdoing.

That may not come as a surprise, since HPD hasn’t found a single police shooting unjustified in at least six years. Between 2007 and 2012, HPD officers fatally shot 109 people and injured another 111. All those shootings were found justified. (For the full story on HPD shootings and beatings, read the Observer investigation here.)

But some expected this case to be different. Claunch was wheelchair-bound and had one arm and one leg. He was definitely aggressive—officers were on the scene because Claunch was agitated, shouting threats and demanding soda and cigarettes—but he was also obviously disabled. HPD reports that Claunch backed an able-bodied officer into a corner and slashed at her with a shiny object, prompting her partner, Matthew Marin, to shoot him. But it’s difficult to visualize Claunch simultaneously moving effectively and posing a serious threat with one arm, even if he had been holding something more deadly than a ballpoint pen. Claunch was also known to be mentally ill; he lived at a small group home for men with mental illness. For all these reasons, some observers expected this shooting to be considered unacceptable.

And at first, it seemed like it would be. Houston’s police chief issued a statement two days later calling Claunch’s death “tragic” and announcing that he’d asked the FBI to investigate. CNN picked up the story, as did The Guardian and The Huffington Post. The Houston Chronicle issued a scathing editorial, stating plainly, “If an officer cannot deal with a mentally ill double amputee waving a silver pen without resorting to deadly violence, then he probably should not be a police officer.” It concluded, “HPD must explore serious reforms. Houston should accept nothing less.”

Yet serious reforms did not come, and Marin is still a police officer. This is despite the fact that Marin had an extensive rap sheet even before Claunch’s killing. It’s notoriously hard to punish an HPD officer (read the Observer’s investigation of HPD’s discipline system here) but Marin racked up 18 disciplinary actions in just five years on the force. These included untruthfulness, misconduct, an at-fault accident, failure to report for duty, failure to complete training, improper police procedure three times and “conduct and behavior” twice. Internal Affairs also cleared Marin in an alleged assault in 2008, and it found no fault in his fatal shooting of a knife-wielding man in October 2009. That suspect had already killed a neighbor and injured his girlfriend when Marin shot him. After killing Claunch, Marin requested a transfer to HPD’s property room, where he remains.

Claunch, too, had a history. The owner of the group home where he lived said Claunch was aggressive but not necessarily violent. Claunch suffered from schizophrenia and bipolar disorder, heard voices and suffered brain damage in the train accident that took his left limbs. After repeated hospitalizations, Claunch became a ward of Harris County in 2003 and was placed in a guardianship program where he stabilized for a few years. But between 2006 and 2010, he stopped taking his medications and was in and out of jail on drug and trespassing charges. An HPD report from 2006 indicates Claunch became aggressive during a trespassing arrest and had to be subdued by a Taser.

Al Tribble, an FBI agent who investigated Claunch’s death, says that record makes a difference. “[If] you get somebody that’s a choir boy, that’s never had a problem in their life…and you’ve got all this force, there’s something wrong with that picture,” he says. “But someone that is prone to violence, that is violent, that’s written down… ‘Hey we had to use these methods to subdue him,’ the finding’s going to be that [the use of force] wasn’t cruel and unusual and it wasn’t excessive.”

The FBI investigation was one of three separate determinations made about Marin’s actions. A grand jury declined to indict Marin in June, HPD has now cleared him, and while the Justice Department has not announced closing the case, Tribble says the FBI’s findings have been sent and he expects no indictments.

CONTINUE READING

, , ,

  • Simon Valentine

    cowardice and illegitimacy are like lawn grass or ‘sports’

    wrong
    stupid
    traditional

  • InfvoCuernos

    This Marin cop sounds like a typical sociopath. No wonder he found his way to the HPD.

  • Jurisrachel

    Well, that’s dicked up.

  • Haystack

    The police approach to any conflict is to overwhelm with force, because that poses the least risk to themselves…maybe they just need their guns, tasers and pepper spray taken away for a while, so they can learn the some conflict resolution skills.

  • Liam_McGonagle

    “Constituency of One”. One muthaf*cka with a gun, a badge and no accountability.

  • doodahman

    holding a pen eh? Must have been that arch criminal, the Penguin.

21
More in Federal Bureau of Investigation, Houston Police Department, Murder
Forensic Psychiatrist: Women Kill More Creatively Than Men

Sigrun Rossmanith and Spiegel Online talk about gender roles and the underestimated shadow of women. via Spiegel Online International Women rarely commit murder, but forensic psychiatrist Sigrun Rossmanith has treated...

Close