The Strange Case of the ‘Time Travel’ Murder

Bright orange nail tipsThe set up for this tale reads like a really clever Scandi-crime novel, but it’s a real case from Britain reported by BBC News:

A woman’s body is found in London. DNA turns up a hit, yet the suspect apparently died weeks before the alleged victim. Here, forensic scientist Dr Mike Silverman tells the story of one of the strangest cases of his career.

It was a real-life mystery that could have come straight from the pages of a modern-day detective novel.

A woman had been brutally murdered in London and biological material had been found under her fingernails, possibly indicating that she might have scratched her attacker just before she died.

A sample of the material was analysed and results compared with the National DNA database and quickly came back with a positive match.

The problem was, the “hit” identified a woman who had herself been murdered – a full three weeks before the death of her alleged “victim”.

The killings had taken place in different areas of the capital and were being investigated by separate teams of detectives.

With no sign of a connection between the two women and nothing to suggest they had ever met, the most “likely” scenario was that the samples had been mixed-up or contaminated at the one obvious place that they had come together – the forensic laboratory. A complaint was made by the senior investigating officer.

It was 1997 and I was the national account manager for the Forensic Science Service at the time, so it was my responsibility to find out if a mistake had been made at the laboratory.

My first thought was that perhaps the second victim’s fingernail clipping had been mislabelled and had actually come from the first victim all along. As soon as I started to look at the samples, I could see this wasn’t the case.

The victim had painted her nails with a distinctive leopard skin pattern and the cuttings that had been taken bore the exact same pattern. There was no doubt that they were the correct ones…

[continues at BBC News]


Majestic is gadfly emeritus.

Latest posts by majestic (see all)

1 Comment on "The Strange Case of the ‘Time Travel’ Murder"

  1. Echar Lailoken | Apr 28, 2014 at 7:23 pm |

    I figured a freezer had something to do with it. My thoughts wandered to Richard Kuklinski and one of his methods of confusing the forensic pathologists.

Comments are closed.