Almost everyone involved in developing Tor was (or is) funded by the US Government

Tor-logo-2011-flatTor users, beware. Yasha Levine casts doubt on the privacy of the dark net’s favorite anonymity tool, at Pando:

“The United States government can’t simply run an anonymity system for everybody and then use it themselves only. Because then every time a connection came from it people would say, “Oh, it’s another CIA agent.” If those are the only people using the network.”

—Roger Dingledine, co-founder of the Tor Network, 2004

In early July, hacker Jacob Appelbaum and two other security experts published a blockbuster story in conjunction with the German press. They had obtained leaked top secret NSA documents and source code showing that the surveillance agency had targeted and potentially penetrated the Tor Network, a widely used privacy tool considered to be the holy grail of online anonymity.

Internet privacy activists and organizations reacted to the news with shock. For the past decade, they had been promoting Tor as a scrappy but extremely effective grassroots technology that can protect journalists, dissidents and whistleblowers from powerful government forces that want to track their every move online. It was supposed to be the best tool out there. Tor’s been an integral part of EFF’s “Surveillance Self-Defense” privacy toolkit. Edward Snowden is apparently a big fan, and so is Glenn Greenwald, who says it “allows people to surf without governments or secret services being able to monitor them.”

But the German exposé  showed Tor providing the opposite of anonymity: it singled out users for total NSA surveillance, potentially sucking up and recording everything they did online.

To many in the privacy community, the NSA’s attack on Tor was tantamount to high treason: a fascist violation of a fundamental and sacred human right to privacy and free speech.

The Electronic Frontier Foundation believes Tor to be “essential to freedom of expression.” Appelbaum — a Wikileaks volunteer and Tor developer — considers volunteering for Tor to be a valiant act on par with Hemingway or Orwell “going to Spain to fight the Franco fascists” on the side of anarchist revolutionaries.

It’s a nice story, pitting scrappy techno-anarchists against the all-powerful US Imperial machine. But the facts about Tor are not as clear cut or simple as these folks make them out to be…

Let’s start with the basics: Tor was developed, built and financed by the US military-surveillance complex. Tor’s original — and current — purpose is to cloak the online identity of government agents and informants while they are in the field: gathering intelligence, setting up sting operations, giving human intelligence assets a way to report back to their handlers — that kind of thing…

[continues at at Pando]


Majestic is gadfly emeritus.

Latest posts by majestic (see all)

11 Comments on "Almost everyone involved in developing Tor was (or is) funded by the US Government"

  1. BuzzCoastin | Jul 17, 2014 at 9:08 pm |

    since I knew from the gitgo it was CIPay funded
    I never assumed it was secure or protected privacy
    and the fall of Silkroad proved it
    same same that super-encryption stuff, vpnz & cryptocurrencies

    TOR was suposed to be a tool for CIA agents
    working to destabilize uncolonized gruberments
    and it still is

    • Simon Valentine | Jul 17, 2014 at 9:32 pm |

      it’s the hogs’ We Break You Buy Policey

      “we can’t teach’m?”
      “wtf does that mean?”
      *co-inter glance*
      “it’s farm’n time!”

  2. erte4wt4etrg | Jul 17, 2014 at 9:24 pm |

    Guess i won’t be using THAT anymore

    • Simon Valentine | Jul 17, 2014 at 9:28 pm |

      i nearly laughed myself forwards out of my chair
      caught myself with my fingers

  3. If anyone had bothered reading the “About” section of their website, they’d have already known this.

  4. Anarchy Pony | Jul 17, 2014 at 10:16 pm |

    Can’t say I’m surprised.

  5. I just figured it was a big giant red flag, basically saying, “hey, spy on me, bitches.”

  6. When I first read about the Tor network
    I saw a million red flags unfurling
    in my mind, and I hoped it was nothing
    but me, growing old and distrustful.

    But in this case the distrust was correct,
    learning that the laugher I heard around me
    was the government, watching the criminals
    hiding in the ultimate honeypot trap.

    I AM growing old and distrustful
    as the distrust keeps getting earned….

  7. InfvoCuernos | Jul 18, 2014 at 1:46 am |

    Brought to you by the same people that give us Muslim extremists that are really FBI informants, CIA agents that smuggle drugs into the US, and ATF agents that sell guns to the Drug Cartels.

  8. Craig Bickford | Jul 18, 2014 at 4:17 am |

    I’m not sure this is news, a lot of people already knew this…

  9. Craig Bickford | Jul 18, 2014 at 4:17 am |

    It was also certainly not a secret that it was being developed by the government, that was the whole point.

Comments are closed.