[Excerpted from Transcendence: The Disinformation Encyclopedia of Transhumanism and the Singularity by R.U. Sirius and Jay Cornell]
Empowering individuals and transcending what were long considered human limits: these goals are exciting to some, but they’re disturbing and frightening to others. Let’s put major objections to transhumanism into one or more of four categories: that it’s unfeasible, directly dangerous, indirectly dangerous, or immoral.
“IT WON’T WORK!”
It’s easy to be skeptical about technological predictions. After all, nobody commutes by personal helicopter or nuclear-powered automobile, or has a kitchen robot cooking dinner. Nuclear power never made electricity “too cheap to meter,” and controlled fusion has been twenty years away for about sixty years now . . . and still is.
Some say that mind uploading is impossible, pointing to the assumptions implicit in the concept: the idea that “you” (your self, mind, or soul) is something distinct from your body.This philosophical dualism is seen as inconsistent with the materialism transhumanists otherwise profess.… Read the rest